top of page

Will Improv Training Actually Improve Team Communication?

Writer: Terry Withers
Terry Withers
5 days ago
7 min read

The Short Answer


I do think the answer is yes.


Usually.


But not always.


Improv can do a lot for a team that’s struggling to communicate. It can also do very little, depending on what is actually causing the struggle. So before you bring in someone like me, it’s worth knowing which kind of problem you have.


What Improv Can Fix


Improv improves communication in two main ways.


The first is practical. Improv builds your verbal ability to communicate: listening closely, responding in the moment, and saying what you mean clearly enough that someone else can understand and respond to it. That’s the whole job of an improviser on stage, so of course there are many improv exercises and games that directly work on sharpening this skill.


(If your scene partner says you’re in a submarine and you respond like you’re in a bakery, well that might make the scene more difficult. That's the reason so many exercises have been developed by improvisers.)


The second is attitudinal. Improv changes how people think about communication in general. And this is the part I find most powerful.


You Succeed Together or You Fail Together


Here’s the principle I come back to again and again: when two people are communicating, there is no way for one person to succeed and the other to fail. You either succeed together or you fail together.


I learned long before I was doing improv that this simple truth isn't obvious to everyone. I spent years in ad sales, including at the New York Times and American Banker, and one thing I heard often from my colleagues, from many different sales departments, went something like this:


“I explained to this prospect why our product would help them, and they just didn’t get it. That person is clueless!”


My coworkers blamed the prospective client for not understand their value proposition. And I did the same thing, I wasn't innocent of this crime.


Doesn't get you very far.


And I get the frustration. I’ve felt it. But the job of sales isn’t to identify people who are clueless.


The job of sales is to communicate value, so that if a product or service can help someone, they understand what it is and why it would be good for them.


This corporate team at Capital One learned some powerful communication strategies and had a great time doing it!
This corporate team at Capital One learned some powerful communication strategies and had a great time doing it!

If they don’t understand what you explained, you both failed. If they do, you both succeeded. That’s all there is to it.


This dynamic is at work far beyond sales. When a manager gets frustrated a direct report didn't understand a task, it is at play. When a colleague bad mouths a teammate for not comprehending a request, it is once again at play.


In fact any time there is a communication breakdown between two teammates, it isn’t one person’s problem. It is both people’s problem every time.


Improv implores us to not find scapegoats , but to instead accept group responsibility. If a manager can’t get a message across to a team of six, that isn’t just the manager’s problem. It’s seven people’s problem, because all seven are failing to communicate together.


Bending to Your Listener


So what’s the fix? Figuring out how people need to be communicated with.


That means two things:

  • Delivering a message in the way the other person needs to hear it

  • Listening in a way that helps you understand what someone else is actually trying to say


In improv we call this bending to the other person. And improv has an absolute abundance of exercises built to train it. Games like One Word Story and Yes And Conversations only work if you’re paying close attention to your partner and adjusting to what they give you.


You can’t plan your brilliant line in advance. You have to listen, adapt, and build.


That skill transfers to everything. Verbal communication, sure. But also writing, nonverbal communication, and even organizational communication (for example, compensation plans communicate very loudly, and plenty of them communicate the wrong thing).


You have to understand your listener in order to communicate successfully with them. It isn't enough to know what you mean, you have to understand also how they will interpret your message.


What Improv Can’t Fix


While the attitudinal lessons of communication that improv imparts are great, it can't fix everything.


If your team struggles to communicate because of a technology bottleneck, a broken workflow, or an organizational structure that keeps information from reaching the right people, improv isn’t going to solve that.


It might help you identify the problem. But so could a myriad of other solutions and improv isn't particularly well suited for that type of strategic work. It certainly can’t rewire your org chart or fix your ticketing system.


I remember one client in Nashville came to me for a communication workshop for members of their sales and fulfillment teams. "They just can't seem to communicate with each other, even simple pieces of information get lost," I was told.


Well the way they were asked to communicate with each other was through a complicated web of databases, three for prospective clients and three more for active clients. As if this wasn't enough, there were also three more "archived" databases that were still used on a daily basis, even though they were "archived".


Important messages from one department to another might live anywhere in any of these 9 databases, and so both teams spent most of there time scouring through these data jungles looking to unearth messages that might have simply been emailed instead.


That's not a communication skills issue, it is an unreasonable impediment to communication erected by managers who meant well, but were operating the company with a serious blindspot.


So, if the issue is that someone is trying to get an idea across to another person and that person isn’t getting it, improv can help a lot. But if the issue is structural, like the company with the 9 databases, there is very little improv can do.


A Story About Diagnosing the Wrong Problem


Here’s an example that taught me a great deal.


I’ve worked for years with the IT department of a Fortune 500 company. It’s a fantastic department, full of people who know their profession inside and out. But when they first came to me they had a persistent problem.


Whenever they rolled out new technology, whether software or physical equipment, and explained to the rest of the company how to use it, the message never seemed to land.


Consequently they hired me for a storytelling workshop. They’d already diagnosed the problem: they weren’t telling a compelling enough story when explaining how to use each new tool. For that reason the message got lost.


So I came in and delivered a great improv-based storytelling workshop (if I do say so myself). And I think their storytelling really did improve.

But that wasn’t the issue.


The Real Problem Was on the Other End


We figured out the real problem during a follow up call months after the workshop.


The client happily reported that yes, their people were telling better stories, but their messages still weren’t getting through. I asked to see some examples and what was shared were simple, easy to understand messages that came not just with directions, but were nestled inside of whys and wherefores, explaining the critical business reasons these new technologies, and surrounding procedures, were being implemented.


It was all crystal clear, easy for anyone to understand.


The problem wasn’t the people delivering the message. It was the people receiving it.


The folks IT was trying to reach were very busy, many of them working largely on commission. They didn’t want to hear the message. They didn’t see the IT team as having the authority to tell them how to work, and frankly, they saw IT as a time-sucking obstacle to their day to day success.


You can tell the most beautiful story in the world, and it won’t matter if your audience has already decided you’re in their way.


Getting Both Sides in the Room


So we changed course. First, we ran an improv based communication workshop with a group of senior executives from those other departments. Then we ran a second workshop that brought them together with leaders from the IT department.


Because communication is a collaboration. You need two parties: one who wants to deliver a message and one who wants to receive it. And then there is a necessary back and forth, because while you might want to deliver a message, the other person may know something that should change how that message is shaped.


The new approach worked. After those workshops, the department found it much easier to explain not just how to use new technology, but why it mattered. And people were finally able to hear it, accept it, and collaborate.


Because now both parties wanted to communicate, whereas before they hadn't. An attitudinal solution. The type of solution improv often directs us to.


A Note on Proof


I’ll be transparent. I don’t have hard numbers on adoption rates or support tickets from that engagement. I never asked for them, and the client never offered.


What I do have is this: that client has kept working with me for almost a decade since. They’ve never asked me to focus on storytelling or communication again. Instead, we’ve worked on confidence, team building, and collaboration.


I take that as a pretty good sign the communication work stuck.


So, Will Improv Training Actually Improve Your Team’s Communication?


That's the big question right, will Improv Training Actually Improve Team Communication? Here’s how I’d think about it.


Improv training is likely to help if:

  • People on your team are talking past each other

  • Messages get delivered but don’t land

  • Teams or departments have stopped listening to each other

  • Folks are more focused on sounding smart than being understood

  • There is obvious acrimony or distrust



Improv training probably won’t help much if:

  • Information gets lost because of tools or workflow

  • Your org structure keeps the right people out of the loop

  • The problem is really about resources, staffing, or incentives


And one more lesson from the IT story: make sure you’ve diagnosed the right problem. My client from that story was smart, thoughtful, and still wrong about what was going on.


That’s normal. A good communication facilitator should help you figure out whether the issue is with the people sending the message, the people receiving it, both (it’s usually both) or from another source altogether.


Here’s the good news.


If you saw your team in that first list, you’ve already done the hardest part. You’ve spotted a people problem, and people problems are exactly what improv is built for. When everyone’s listening closely, adapting to each other and owning the outcome together, messages start landing.


Because you succeed together or you fail together. So what’s going on with your team right now: a people problem, a structural one, or (let’s be honest) a little of both? If you see a people problem at your company consider reaching out for a proposal from Radical Agreement, we can help!

Comments


bottom of page